It’s official — you’re engaged, and your wedding playlist is starting to take shape. But when it came time for our first dance song, we were stumped. We Googled, we Spotify’d, and we searched through blog after blog… only to find the same handful of songs we’d heard at every wedding we’ve ever been to. Don’t get us wrong — they’re beautiful classics, but they didn’t feel like us.

So, we did what any determined couple would do — we made our own playlist. After countless hours of listening, we curated a list of songs that felt real, romantic, and right for our first dance. Now, we’re sharing our top 10 favorite first dance songs that you might not have heard 100 times before — but you’ll definitely want to use.

(And yes, you can find our full Spotify playlist right here!)

For the Classic Bride:

01. At Last by Etta James

A timeless favorite that easily earns its spot. It captures the magic of finally finding the one, and Etta’s vocals make it feel like your love story belongs in a vintage movie. Romantic, elegant, unforgettable.

02. Can’t Help Falling in Love by Haley Reinhart

We know this one’s been done, but this version adds a unique, soulful twist. Haley’s vocals bring softness and intimacy, making it feel brand new even if the lyrics are familiar.

For the Modern Bride:

03. Never Stop by SafetySuit

A ballad that’s all about the everyday promises of marriage — not just the grand gestures, but the small, meaningful ones. Raw, sweet, and full of heart.

04. Forever Like That by Ben Rector

With poetic lyrics and mellow acoustic vibes, this one captures the everyday rhythm of a strong marriage. It’s understated, honest, and completely charming.

For the Country Bride:

5. Tuesdays by Jake Scott

It’s not just about the wedding — it’s about every Tuesday after. This song speaks to real-life love: steady, deep, and lasting.

6. In Case You Didn’t Know by Brett Young

A simple confession of love, this country hit still holds up as a heartfelt and sincere option — especially if you’re a couple who values emotion over flash.

7. From the Ground Up by Dan + Shay

This one deserves way more attention. Inspired by legacy and lasting love, it’s perfect for couples building their own story with deep roots.

For the Christian Bride:

8. I Get to Love You by Ruelle

This isn’t a song about obligation — it’s a song about privilege. Soft, graceful, and God-honoring, this one is a tearjerker in the best way.

9. Hundred More Years by Francesca Battistelli

For the couple who’s been through seasons together already or grew up together — this song celebrates that sweet, steadfast love with a faith-filled lens.

10. Unfailing Love by Jimmy Needham

A worshipful, Christ-centered song that celebrates the covenant of marriage and reflects God’s love through a husband’s vow. Pure, powerful, and perfect for couples whose faith is at the center of their relationship.

---

Got a favorite? Share this post with a friend or let us know in the comments what your first dance song is! We’re always looking for new favorites to add to the playlist.

Father-Daughter Dance Songs